![]() |
11:28 PM CDT on Saturday, August 13, 2005
It comes as no surprise that Americans are under severe stress due to
crushing debt levels and a savings rate that is basically zero. It's not
surprising because we are encouraged to over-consume by nearly every
facet of culture and media. Worse, we have internalized consumerism to
the point where it has become our value system.As media critic Mark
Crispin Miller told me recently, we have been reduced to being
"receivers of messages that constantly tell us that the only thing that
matters in life is to go shopping and then stay home with your stuff."
Which is, as he says, "profoundly anti-democratic."
Multimedia: Images, audio impressions of the Collin County lifestyle Collin comparisons: Map, quiz Special Report: The Price of Prosperity
We have replaced the model of "citizen" with the model of "consumer."
The citizen model encouraged group involvement, debate and community.
The consumer model encourages immediate gratification and personal
indulgence. It replaces the real empowerment of civic engagement with a
fantasy of empowerment enabled through consumer products.
And not only has the role of consumer become our primary function in
society, it has, in large respects, become our religion.
The new Ikea is like the big blue consumer cathedral of Frisco,
dominating the landscape like the pyramids (except much uglier). And the
hype surrounding its opening is like any new blip on the shopping
landscape: its novelty arouses us for a short while, but then we're on
the hunt again for the next promise of material salvation.
And if consumerism is our new religion, one aspect is conspicuously
absent: the ethical one. We shop without considering the larger
ramifications of our purchases. How and where was this product made? Who
and what am I supporting by paying for this thing? How are the workers
treated? (What's the difference between Wal-Mart and Costco, for
example?)
We are encouraged to isolate the buying experience into how it will make
us feel in the moment and to ignore the larger effects. These days the
effects reach all around the world.
And, as Americans, we like to think we have a system and ideas worthy of
exporting to the world. If the American Dream has degenerated into a
consumer dystopia, we might want to do some rethinking.
Here, in the wealthiest county in Texas, we serve as a kind of model. It
is an unsustainable ideal. Our hyper-consumptive, supersized lifestyle
is a disastrous example for the rest of the world. Especially in booming
places like China, where, if everyone drove the aptly named Suburban and
bought oversized houses, the environment would literally collapse.
Some say "personal responsibility" is the answer. True enough when it's
a fair fight, but it's not. As individuals we are grossly outmatched by
enormous propaganda campaigns, market studies, Ivy League psychologists
and "perception managers" who do just that – manage our perceptions of
everything. Sadly, they also manage the perceptions we have of ourselves.
This is especially offensive when it comes to our children. The
marketing most of us were subjected to growing up seems quaint compared
to the industry that is aggressively targeting the youth of today.
Our kids are being trained to be good consumers, which is certainly not
the same thing as being a good person or a good American. Girls get
shopping mall games and boys get mini-Hummers, the very symbol of
excessive, wasteful consumption.
And everything is branded. Few well-designed toys exist that are not
cross-selling something else: sugary snacks, sugary pop idols, animated
characters.
Walking through a mega toy store you get the sense that life is nothing
but a series of acquisitions. That basically childhood is a matter of
working your way through the different departments, front to back. Then
you get to head to the big box stores and the SUV lot. Then you get a
starter castle. Your identity is defined by what you have, even if it's
the same thing everyone else has.
If consumerism has replaced citizenship, then the more stuff you have,
the higher your status. And as long as status is equated with stuff, our
personal, financial and civic lives will continue to deteriorate. It's
good for the marketers, but it's bad for democracy.
The American philosopher William James said that worship of success was
our national disease. The problem is, in order to cure the disease, we
have to admit that we are afflicted in the first place.
Dean Terry of Plano is a writer and professor of arts & humanities.
His film "Subdivided" will be released later this year, and more of his
commentary can be found at deanterry.com. He can be reached at dean@
deanterry.com




